Wednesday, November 22, 2023

by Harish Gupta, National Editor, Lokmat Group

Fly on the Wall


Selective amnesia

An impression has gained ground that Governors appointed by the Modi government are on a warpath with the non-BJP governments in states. The Governors are making the lives of elected governments in states miserable. For example, Jagdeep Dhankhar as Governor of West Bengal was constantly involved in a bitter battle with TMC's Mamata Banerjee which gladdened the hearts of the Prime Minister which finally led him to the coveted post of Vice President. It is no secret that Kerala Governor  Arif Mohammad Khan was in the race for the top post and crossed swords with the Left Front government led by Pinarayi Vijayan on one issue or the other. Tamil Nadu Governor R N Ravi has also been involved in a bitter battle with the M K Stalin government. The Supreme Court finally stepped in when the matter came to head over Governors sitting over files relating to bills sent by respective state governments for approval.  Lately, Banwarilal Purohit who was sent to Punjab, also did the same to Bhagwant Singh Mann government. But not all the governors crossed swords with Opposition-ruled states  and many of them enjoy cordial relations with them. For example, Thaawar Chand Gehlot, Governor of Karnataka and Congress Chief Minister Siddharamiah have extremely cordial relations so far. Rajasthan Governor Kalraj Mishra is a good host to Congress Chief Minister Ashok Gehlot though PM Modi bitterly accuses him of many scams and ED is also after his family members. 

 

Similarly, Chhattisgarh Governor Biswabhusan Harichandan is having a harmonious relationship with the Bhupesh Baghel government. The Telangana Governor, Tamilsai Soundararajan is another example of cordiality with the Chief Minister, K Chandrashekhar Rao. Even her Andhra Pradesh counter-part Justice S. Abdul Nazeer has been maintaining extremely cordial relations with Jaganmohan Redy government. The same goes for the Odisha Governor, Raghubar Das. Even his predecessor Ganeshi Lal enjoyed good relations with Chief Minister Naveen Patnaik. There is no explanation as to why some states are witnessing this selective amnesia.


Tit For Tat 

The Congress may be flexing its muscles in the expectation of winning Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh Assembly polls and claiming to have an edge in Telangana as well over BRS' K Chandrashekhar Rao. The Congress refused to share any seat with any of its INDIA allies in the Assembly polls. The Congress’ argument was that  the INDIA alliance is for the Lok Sabha polls only. The allies are now waiting to give the Congress back in the same coin in the Lok Sabha polls. Be it JMM in Jharkhand, Samajwadi Party in UP or even RJD in Bihar, all are upset with the Congress and in no mood to allocate more Lok Sabha seats to Congress than it actually deserves in 2024. Of the 134 Lok Sabha seats in UP, Bihar & Jharkhand, the Congress could barely win three in the 2019 General Elections. Even these three seats were won by the Congress in alliance & adjustment with these parties. If the Samajwadi Party lent it’s helping hand in UP, the RJD was an ally in Bihar and the JMM was with the Congress in Jharkhand. The Congress contested nine seats in Jharkhand in alliance with RJD & JMM leaving only five for them but  could win one seat. In UP, the SP-BSP-RLD were in alliance and showed magnanimity by leaving two seats- RaeBareli and Amethi – for Sonia Gandhi and Rahul Gandhi respectively. Yet, Rahul Gandhi lost the seat while Sonia Gandhi retained with a slander margin. In Bihar too, the Congress contested 11 seats out of 40 and could win one only. Therefore, angry allies may not share seats with the Congress liberally in 2024. The RJD has made it clear that it will share only 8 Lok Sabha seats and not 11 as was the case in 2019. It intends to give three seats to other smaller allies like the Vikasheel Insan Party, etc. In Jharkhand, the JMM is unwilling to give more than 7 seats. In UP, the SP may concede 5 seats only. A tit for tat indeed.

 Emergence of another Yogi

The BJP may have found going tough in Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh. But pollsters are predicting an easy win for the BJP in Rajasthan as the faction-ridden party finally closed ranks. The front-runner Vasundhararaje Scindia was in all smiles as the high command accommodated in giving Assembly tickets to her supporters. However, the BJP fielded many Lok Sabha MPs in the Assembly polls including Rajyavardhan Singh Rathore and Diya Kumari. But the most surprising pick was Mahant Balak Nath who brands himself as ‘Rajasthan ka Yogi’. The Alwar MP Balak Nath is testing his electoral fortunes from the Tijara Assembly seat which the BJP won only once in five decades. The constituency is dominated by Yadavs, Muslims, and Dalits. The Mahant belongs to the Nath sect of Hinduism and was born into a Yadav family. If the BJP insiders are to be believed, Balak Nath could be a surprise pick for the top job. No one has a clue as to why he was picked as he hails from Haryana and fielded in the Lok Sabha from Rajasthan in 2019. Balak Nath was seen even touching the feet of Yogi Adityanath when he came to campaign for him. But many in the BJP say that Balak Nath is being groomed as a rival to Yogi Adityanath. The rise of Balak Nath has given jitters to many in the state as well. It transpires that the RSS was also in favour of grooming him as he is an OBC while Yogi Adityanath is a Rajput.