Tuesday, January 6, 2015

2015: Test of Modi's management skills and luck


by Harish Gupta, National Editor, Lokmat Group

To those who have a casual interest in astrology which, I emphasize, is not a science, 2014 was a significant year. It was marked by transition of the Saturn, supposedly the most malefic of all the planets, from the Scorpio sign to Sagittarius. In the two-and-a-half years of the Saturn's residence in a zodiacal sign, the remote and 'cold' planet supposedly causes life-changing happenings of those born under the signs immediately before and after its extant address. Astrologers give much importance to this seven-and-a-half-years period (2.5X3), popularly known in India as saade saati, which, it is generally believed, can be one of 'creative destruction', or just destruction, depending on their clients' native chart. 

I wish to bid goodbye here to the world of astrology but retain the metaphor of saade saati to guess what 2015 portends for India, be it happy or ominous. Much of the way things pan out for the country will surely depend on Prime Minister Narendra Modi's quality of leadership as BJP has indeed become a one-man party and so has NDA. And, more importantly, he is winning election after election, despite a waning wave. The 'secular' forces are dying to give him a fight. But they're just dying. Reduced in the Lok Sabha to a minority of characters as dissimilar as passengers booked on Noah's Ark (Mamata's men and CPM), the opposition thought they'd counterpunch in the Rajya Sabha where the Modi brigade is in minority. But they soon discovered that Modi could play Gulliver and turn them Lilliputian, taking the bills they'd stalled to the President and coming back winner with a volley of ordinances.

The old land acquisition law that Mamata had resisted at Singur in 2006, giving, in turn, not only herself the government in West Bengal but bright ideas to the Congress leadership to twist the Central law, is back almost to its original form, thanks to Modi's ordinance onslaught. And so is the law to raise foreign stake limit in the insurance firm, and to change the relevant clauses in the Indira Gandhi-made law to nationalize the coal mines that'll make room for private firms—both domestic and foreign—to run nearly 200 coal blocks. Since he is only following the Supreme Court order, no amount of opposition by others can block the move. Moreover, Modi will introduce all nine Ordinances in Lok Sabha first, get them passed and send them to the Rajya Sabha. If the Opposition-controlled Rajya Sabha does otherwise, Modi has the option to summon joint session of Parliament to have his way. These come along with a big step towards making India a common market by securing cabinet approval for a bill that promises a Goods and Services Tax. And all that comes gift-wrapped with falling oil prices, a relief that can come only in a dream. 

It is a good overture to a saade saati play, more creative than destructive. If it goes on, the Indian growth rate may catch up with China in the course of this year as claimed by Finance Minister Arun Jaitley. Who knows ? And then Modi can don the same hat that ex-Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh did as the reformer Finance Minister post-1991. But three things must happen for that. Oil price must stay low, FDI should rain in, and enough jobs must be created for demand to look up. 

Crude oil accounts for 70 per cent of India's import so the importance of its cost remaining within manageable limits cannot be overstated. But its continuance at the $ 60+ level depends on the US and Saudi Arabia and the convergence of their geo-political interests—be it Iran or Russia. If oil goes back to its former Himalayan abode of $ 120, it will recoil in subsequent election results and the party may be over. FDI, similarly, depends more on extraneous developments than on India's internal situation. With the economies of Europe and Japan in utter disarray, emerging markets including China slowing down, the US is the only beacon fire. And its economy is doing well; it is poised to notch up a 4 per cent growth. This success can trigger the Federal Reserve to raise rates and the temptation to put funds in a stable market may block the flow of US investments to risky emerging markets for a long time to come. Modi may change the laws to make them investor friendly but little can he do if there is no investor around. The Indian market will then be all dressed up and nowhere to go. Finally, on the business of job creation, Modi has coined the slogan 'Make in India' but has not yet even tried to walk the talk. The cold fact is, labour intensity of all jobs is declining, be that manufacturing, industry, services, even agriculture. All this may be because of UPA's follies as between 2005 and 2012, India added only 15 million new jobs. The pace of job creation is even more stunted now. So there is not much hope of the current saade saati witnessing much improvement in the composition of India's 'common man'. 

To many Indians, Modi is still the new avatar of a mythological god who’d fix the bad guy and save the oppressed. We’ve seen, though, that the “creative” side of the ‘Modi saade saati’ is quite independent of him.
  
2015 can be the best of time for Modi for factors on which he has little control. But there were things he could do to ensure that the high expectation he has raised doesn’t backfire on him if things don’t work out according to plan. And expectation rises for words he utters like ‘Make in India’ and a Swachh Bharat project.  Congress leader Jairam Ramesh has parsed his acronym NaMo as “No Action, Message Only”.  If 2015 brings no result as planned by Modi, Ramesh may get an audience.

Modi’s another challenge in 2015 will be to keep Sangh Parivar on his side. The “Ghar Vapasi” program dented his image to a large extent largely because he went into a shell. It’s a different matter his silence resulted in the ouster of Rajeshwar Singh from the program itself. But Praveen Togadia has returned home after several years as working president of the VHP. Earlier, he had been banished as working president of VHP “International”.  The anti-Modi groups within the frontal organisations of the RSS and in his own government will keep firing one missile or the other. It will be the real test of his skill in 2015.

(The author is 
National Editor, 
 Lokmat group)