by Harish Gupta, National Editor, Lokmat Group
As a joke, it is clever but contrived. As a jibe in parliament, it is rank graceless. Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s latest remark in the Rajya Sabha about his predecessor Dr. Manmomohan Singh—only Doctor saab knows the art of bathing wearing a raincoat in the bathroom—looks like having put paid to the budget session when it resumes on March 9 after a month-long adjournment. The Congress, which is Lilliputian in the Lok Sabha but ‘big brother’ in the Upper House, has threatened to keep out of the rest of the session if Modi doesn’t apologize. And that’s asking for the moon unless the stand is changed after March 11.
However, beyond the frightening display of “indigestion” at the highest level of India’s political life, the incident also highlights just what CPI(M) party chief and Rajya Sabha member Sitaram Yechury remarked, that it is not a reply (to President’s address) but an election speech. For that matter, on demonetisation, none from the treasury benches, including the Prime Minister, ventured to respond to the fact of the GDP dropping a full percentage point post-note ban. During the winter session, it was Dr Singh who had got Modi’s goatby forecasting that GDP would be dented by a percentage point, and even upped the ante, in an uncharacteristic way, by calling demonetisation as “organized loot” and “legalized plunder”. Dr Manmohan Singh’s sharp attack on the Modi government surprised all because he rarely spoke in such strong words before, even when Rahul Gandhi tore his Ordinance in full public view. Modi who was sitting in the Rajya Sabha then, kept his cool and waited for an opportune time to strike back. And when he did, all hell broke.
Congress’ leaders did their best to counter Modi’s offensive, but it was not enough. BJP president Amit Shah promptly sprinkled salt on the wound by reminding Congress vice president Rahul Gandhi about his mother Sonia Gandhi’s famous invective at Modi during the days when he was chief minister of riot-hit Gujarat, that he’s maut ka saudagar (merchant of death). Shah did a bit more chest-thumping as he claimed that BJP has given a prime minister who “speaks” and before him “there was one whose voice could be heard only by you and your mother”.
It is evident that if the existing ill will between BJP and Congress continues—and there is not a snowball’s chance in hell that it will go anytime soon—there will hardly be any significant legislative action in the present Lok Sabha. Modi’s ‘raincoat’ jibe was undoubtedly unbecoming of him, but so was Manmohan Singh’s “organised loot” and “plunder”, words that the Prime Minister said Singh had been “made to utter” (implying off-stage prompting by the Congress president). Looking backward, it is obvious that what was mere obstructionism by BJP during UPA 1 (2004-09) turned into splenetic outbursts in the UPA 2 (2009-14) period, when the opposition led by BJP blocked every legislative move by the UPA. Political analysts gave it a sober name, ‘policy paralysis’, but it was actually a series of outbursts against the Congress’ dynastic leaders.
Now the table has turned, and it is ‘Modi V. Dynasty’. At an election rally in Haridwar last week, Modi was at the height of vexation with the Congress’ top leadership. “I tell the Congress leaders: hold your tongue, else I have your detailed horoscope. I do not want to desert dignity and reason, but if your desert dignity and reason and speak nonsense, your history will always chase you”. It can well be empty bluster; but who knows if it has ammunition?
Beyond the clash of ego, however, there is a looming threat that the medium to long term effects of demonetisation by the Modi administration may put India on an unexpectedly slippery slope of economic slow growth against strong global headwinds. IMF has trimmed India’s growth forecast for current (2016-17) and next fiscal by one percentage point (giving some credence to Manmohan Singh’s forecast though he said there will be two per cent fall ) and 0.4 percentage point, respectively, primarily to choking of consumption due to cash shortage and payment disruptions across the economy. But the same IMF, in its World Economic Outlook (WEO) update, has upped China’s growth estimate for 2016-17 from 6.5 per cent to 6.7 per cent. China is an aging country with a per capita GDP over five times that of India. It will be difficult, if not impossible, for India to catch up with economies that have raced ahead if it has no national strategy to put its youthful population to productive use. But, going by the Modi-Gandhi feud, national consensus on any issue is unlikely.
It is even more unfortunate that India’s electoral politics does not hold out any prospect for political unanimity on national cause. It is because over time, particularly in the present decade, the two warring parties, BJP and Congress, are increasingly becoming driven by personalities. Modi and the Gandhis, to be precise. If there are others, they’re bit players. Or like new organs growing from original stem cells, like Sasikala has grown out of the late Jayalalithaa of Tamil Nadu. The party system is under pressure, not merely in India but all over. The Grand Old Party of America, the Republican Party, has been totally eclipsed by Trump, who is anything but a republican, be it a small ‘r’ or capital. The British Labour Party is on stretcher and the Conservative Party died with Brexit. In India, the Congress resembled a party in the classical sense so long as it had a full-scale party as its main adversary, the BJP. But the fig-leaf is gone. And a couple of battling individuals have taken the charge to define the destiny of the world’s largest democracy!
